Derek vs Derek (Dawson, 2026)

From my perspective, it feels like there are two types of farming documentaries/films: the kind where audiences witness the butchery of animals and all the slaughter to make one’s favourite meat; and the other that digs a little deeper and explores the personalities behind the farmers and shows how much care they put into their jobs, life and the land. It may still remain true that the slaughter of animals is repulsive and should not be needed, but the way in which award-winning director James Dawson’s latest documentary Derek vs. Derek looks at two farmers, gives the viewer the chance to open their minds — just like Derek might as well.

Two strong-minded men, very clear from the get-go that they are ready to achieve what they want. Derek Banbury (from the Lower Frankaborough Farm) is the third generation of his family’s dairy farm. Prepared to “feed the nation” as he would put it, Banbury is intense when it comes to farming. He puts industrially produced farm food first over the importance of the wildlife that may come into harms way. A generational type of farming, something these workers and people grow up with through family lineage. Banbury and his farming style are presented in an innocent and understanding way, as are all people in Derek vs Derek.

Next door to Banbury is the slightly younger natured Derek Gow (from Rewinding Coombeshead). Gow’s perspective on farming differs from the general farming community, and most definitely his neighbours. A former sheep farmer, Gow has strayed away from the conventional methods. Instead he is out to create something new, a large scale restoration project to restore nature. Beginning small in his property and its surroundings, he hopes to show the world how important it is to make farming sustainable. With at one point, even stating that farming needs to change in order for the world to be liveable.

As much as it is important to see both Derek’s perspectives on farming, it cannot be helped but see the comedy in their banter. They are constantly at each other’s throats, or so you would so casually say. Two different people in their own right, and then further to this, two completely different farmers. All this is presented to the audience entirely as if they do two completely different types of jobs in the world — somehow entirely true.

Over multiple years and seasons in the realm of agriculture, Derek and Derek’s story expands. From an introduction to the land and their roles, Dawson spends the course of the film not only teaching his audience about the industry, but why he chose to document these two individuals themselves. 50 years of experience on his family farm, Banbury has known life like nothing else. But when Gow comes along, things might need to change.

Derek vs Derek is not only a story of two individuals, but a deeper look and reflection of the reality of the world. Almost structured as if to teach the audience more than Banbury, Gow’s explanation as to why the industry must change to stop what is to come, comes across so well structured and informative. Instead of a presentation of the facts in such a boring format, this humorous documentary is more than meets the eye. While it could entirely be a fictional story someone developed, it is in fact life and we must each reflect upon what it wishes to tell us.

Though a documentary, there are additional filmmaking elements that Dawson implements within the film to further dramatize it. Not in a sense that he wants the audience to feel as though the truth is being hidden. But the way in which he uses the score to add tension and keep a steady pace allows for a more enjoyable and entertaining watch. As opposed to the simple silence of nature, the big screen watch gives us the chance to see the farmers in a different light. Adding what you would expect from a fictional story, but amidst two people’s truths and lives.

Whether you know much about farming, agriculture, or even what is going on in those terms when it comes to the state of the world, Derek vs Derek is truly an informative and comedic must watch. Heading out to UK cinemas from Friday 2 October, 2026, do be sure to find yourself watching the two Dereks incredible story together.

Previous
Previous

All of a Sudden (Hamaguchi, 2026) - TIFF ‘26

Next
Next

Julián (Bagnall, 2026) - TIFF ‘26